Top Five Sleep Aids

Note: This article may contain affiliate links. If you click a link and purchase a product, Consumer’s Health Report may receive a commission, which allows us to continue to do our research.

This is where you will find only the brands which passed our lab’s quality analysis. Our quality analysis, which is our basic supplement screening process, simply filters product that do not meet the following criteria:

  • The supplement must contain at least 95% of the ingredient quantity claimed by its label (5% deterioration is the standard allowance for storage and delivery)
  • The supplement must contain NO IMPURITIES OR ADDITIVES

After the screening process, each product is graded according to additional criteria:

  • Variety – an effective sleep supplement needs to have three different ingredients, each of which attacks different threats to our sleep.
  • Supplement diversity – there are various different herbal and other natural supplements included, such as: valerian root, chamomile extract, melatonin, and many others.
  • Potency – the amount of active ingredients within the supplement.
  • Price – self-explanatory, however it is important to remember that in most cases you get what you pay for.
Preview
Best Overall
NeuroScience Serene - Sleep and Mood Support with 5-HTP, Active Folate + B6 (60 Capsules)
LUNA Melatonin-Free Sleep Supplement | Naturally Sourced Sleep Aid Without Melatonin | Valerian Root, Chamomile Extract, Lemon Balm & More | Herbal Non-Habit Forming Sleeping Pill | Non-GMO Vegan Caps
Sleep Aid with Valerian Root, Patented Suntheanine, 100% Natural, Chamomile, Suntheanine & P5P Wake Up Feeling Rested, Sleeping Pills for Adults Extra Strength
Shut Eye Sleep Aid | Natural Herbal Sleep Supplement Made with Valerian Root, Melatonin, Chamomile, Magnesium | Insomnia and Anxiety Relief | Adult Extra Strength Sleeping Pills | 60 Vegan Capsules
Best Price
Puritan's Pride Super Strength Rapid Release Capsules Melatonin 10 Mg, 120Count
Product Title
NeuroScience Serene - Sleep and Mood Support with 5-HTP, Active Folate + B6 (60 Capsules)
LUNA Melatonin-Free Sleep Supplement | Naturally Sourced Sleep Aid Without Melatonin | Valerian Root, Chamomile Extract, Lemon Balm & More | Herbal Non-Habit Forming Sleeping Pill | Non-GMO Vegan Caps
Sleep Aid with Valerian Root, Patented Suntheanine, 100% Natural, Chamomile, Suntheanine & P5P Wake Up Feeling Rested, Sleeping Pills for Adults Extra Strength
Shut Eye Sleep Aid | Natural Herbal Sleep Supplement Made with Valerian Root, Melatonin, Chamomile, Magnesium | Insomnia and Anxiety Relief | Adult Extra Strength Sleeping Pills | 60 Vegan Capsules
Puritan's Pride Super Strength Rapid Release Capsules Melatonin 10 Mg, 120Count
Amazon Prime Benefits
-
Price
$46.00
$21.95
$18.94
$21.89
$6.76
Best Overall
Preview
NeuroScience Serene - Sleep and Mood Support with 5-HTP, Active Folate + B6 (60 Capsules)
Product Title
NeuroScience Serene - Sleep and Mood Support with 5-HTP, Active Folate + B6 (60 Capsules)
Amazon Prime Benefits
Price
$46.00
Preview
LUNA Melatonin-Free Sleep Supplement | Naturally Sourced Sleep Aid Without Melatonin | Valerian Root, Chamomile Extract, Lemon Balm & More | Herbal Non-Habit Forming Sleeping Pill | Non-GMO Vegan Caps
Product Title
LUNA Melatonin-Free Sleep Supplement | Naturally Sourced Sleep Aid Without Melatonin | Valerian Root, Chamomile Extract, Lemon Balm & More | Herbal Non-Habit Forming Sleeping Pill | Non-GMO Vegan Caps
Amazon Prime Benefits
Price
$21.95
Preview
Sleep Aid with Valerian Root, Patented Suntheanine, 100% Natural, Chamomile, Suntheanine & P5P Wake Up Feeling Rested, Sleeping Pills for Adults Extra Strength
Product Title
Sleep Aid with Valerian Root, Patented Suntheanine, 100% Natural, Chamomile, Suntheanine & P5P Wake Up Feeling Rested, Sleeping Pills for Adults Extra Strength
Amazon Prime Benefits
Price
$18.94
Preview
Shut Eye Sleep Aid | Natural Herbal Sleep Supplement Made with Valerian Root, Melatonin, Chamomile, Magnesium | Insomnia and Anxiety Relief | Adult Extra Strength Sleeping Pills | 60 Vegan Capsules
Product Title
Shut Eye Sleep Aid | Natural Herbal Sleep Supplement Made with Valerian Root, Melatonin, Chamomile, Magnesium | Insomnia and Anxiety Relief | Adult Extra Strength Sleeping Pills | 60 Vegan Capsules
Amazon Prime Benefits
-
Price
$21.89
Best Price
Preview
Puritan's Pride Super Strength Rapid Release Capsules Melatonin 10 Mg, 120Count
Product Title
Puritan's Pride Super Strength Rapid Release Capsules Melatonin 10 Mg, 120Count
Amazon Prime Benefits
Price
$6.76

Image of a chart comparing the best sleep supplements


         #1 NeuroScience  Serene

Neuroscience

Neuroscience is a solid company with a great track record of producing quality cognitive health supplements.

The primary active ingredient of this supplement is 5-HTP, a serotonin precursor. This is designed to ensure that your body has what it needs to create sufficient levels of serotonin, a neurotransmitter (chemical) which regulates mood and the sleep-wake cycle.

In addition, Serene contains folate and vitamin B6 which are strongly linked to mood and sleep quality.

Due to very positive consumer feedback and effective amounts of key nutrients, Neuroscience Serene has earned the title of Best Sleep Supplement of 2019.

Overall Score: 4.7/5

Variety: 4 high-quality supplement ingredients

Supplement Diversity: 4.5/5

Potency: 4.8/5

NeuroScience Serene - Sleep and Mood Support with 5-HTP, Active Folate + B6 (60 Capsules)
  • Contains a blend of ingredients important for mood and sleep-wake function*
  • 5-HTP (from Griffonia simplicifolia seed extract): 5-hydroxytryptophan (5-HTP) crosses the blood-brain barrier and is a precursor to serotonin and melatonin [1].* Serotonin is important for regulating mood and sleep-wake function [2].
  • In a randomized, double-blind study, 5-HTP was shown to significantly improve mood [3].*

          #2 Nested  Naturals  Luna  Natural  Sleep  Aid71yGsS1GftL._SY679_

Nested Naturals

Luna is a wonderful, natural herbal sleep supplement which contains a wide variety of calming extracts and amino acids.

More specifically geared towards reducing anxiety and morning grogginess, the blend of chamomile extract, valerian root, and passionflower is highly effective. This supplement also works well for dissipating stress. It is also melatonin-free, which is preferable as melatonin can cause you to feel lethargic upon waking up.

Overall Score: 4.6/5

Variety: 8 high-quality supplement ingredients

Supplement Diversity: 4.8/5

Potency: 4.0/5

LUNA Melatonin-Free Sleep Supplement | Naturally Sourced Sleep Aid Without Melatonin | Valerian Root, Chamomile Extract, Lemon Balm & More | Herbal Non-Habit Forming Sleeping Pill | Non-GMO Vegan Caps
  • A POWERFUL SLEEP AID WITH NO SURPRISES | From the makers of LUNA - the #1 Natural Sleep aid on Amazon, comes a new Melatonin-free option for those who are sensitive to melatonin. Our harmonious blend of relaxing herbs and L-Theanine encourage an easy, restful sleep without grogginess in the morning, wacky dreams or restlessness due to melatonin-sensitivity.
  • HERBAL BLEND FOR A SLEEPY BEDTIME | To make it just as effective as LUNA Original, we’ve rejiggered our complex with some of the most calming, sleep inducing herbs including chamomile extract, valerian root, passionflower, lemon balm and hops.
  • ADDED BOOST OF SOOTHING L-THEANINE | L-Theanine, an amino acid found in green tea, helps the brain create states of relaxation, making it easier to fall asleep, calm stress and extend the duration of deep sleep. It’s a great addition to our wonderful herbal blend.


         #3 Physician’s  Choice  Natural  Sleep  Aid

Overall Score: 4.4/5

Another 100% natural option is Physician’s Choice Sleep Aid. The primary active ingredient Suntheanine is a patented and specially tailored form of the amino acid L-Theanine – an amino acid which is found almost exclusively in tea.

Physician’s Choice is a reputable company with a solid background in health supplements. Consumers loved this product of theirs in particular, as feedback has been overwhelmingly positive.

Variety: 8 high-quality supplement ingredients

Supplement Diversity: 4.8/5

Potency: 4.0/5

Sale
Sleep Aid with Valerian Root, Patented Suntheanine, 100% Natural, Chamomile, Suntheanine & P5P Wake Up Feeling Rested, Sleeping Pills for Adults Extra Strength
  • DEEP SLEEP DOCTOR-APPROVED SLEEPING PILLS: Fall asleep fast and stay asleep. We saw a need for high-quality supplements that actually work. Too many companies are selling potions and powders that have no clinical research or don't work. As lifelong supplement enthusiasts, we create products that really work and are proven to work from clinical research.
  • NATURAL SLEEP AID, AWARD-WINNING & PATENTED INGREDIENT: Drug-free, 100% natural ingredients. No hangover, wake up feeling fully energized, refreshed and rested with optimal mental clarity. Made with Suntheanine L-Theanine.
  • WAKE FEELING REFRESHED AND ENERGIZED: Our Sleep Aid is formulated with a powerful combination of clinically proven ingredients to help you get restful sleep and feel refreshed when you wake up in the morning.

          #4 Nuvana  Shut  Eye

Overall Score: 4.3/5

Variety: 9 high-quality supplement ingredients

Supplement Diversity: 4.2/5

Potency: 4.4/5

Shut Eye Sleep Aid | Natural Herbal Sleep Supplement Made with Valerian Root, Melatonin, Chamomile, Magnesium | Insomnia and Anxiety Relief | Adult Extra Strength Sleeping Pills | 60 Vegan Capsules
  • SLEEP WELL, WAKE UP REVITALIZED | If you’re feeling tired and seeking better sleep, then it’s time to get some Shut Eye! An all-natural, maximum strength and non-habit forming herbal sleep aid, Shut Eye is designed to re-balance your overtaxed system for restful sleep. Expertly crafted and tested by a renowned neurologist, Dr. Okhovat, who set out to improve deeper sleep for all. You’ll wake up feeling refreshed and energized without the groggy side effect associated with other sleep aids.
  • A BOOST OF SOOTHING MAGNESIUM, L-THEANINE & MORE | L-Theanine is an amino acid found in green tea; GABA is a neurotransmitter produced by the body. They both help the brain to down-regulate feelings of worry and create states of relaxation, which may make it easier to fall asleep and extend the duration of deep sleep. Magnesium, also known as the ‘relaxation mineral’, aids in calming your mind and muscles
  • MADE IN THE U.S.A. | in an FDA-Registered facility. This product is GMP (Good Manufacturing Practice)-certified to assure the highest quality and purity.

         #5 Puritan’s Pride Super Snooze With Melatonin

Overall Score: 4.1/5

Variety: 8 high-quality supplement ingredients

Supplement Diversity: 4.8/5

Potency: 4.0/5

Puritan's Pride Super Strength Rapid Release Capsules Melatonin 10 Mg, 120Count
  • Nighttime sleep aid
  • Super strength
  • Fall asleep quickly and stay asleep longer

Recommended Articles

Black text on a yellow background that says "lactobacillus bulgaricus" and a graphic of a bacterial cell

Lactobacillus Bulgaricus: A Probiotic Strain

Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn EmailLactobacillus bulgaricus, also known as Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus is a member of the acidophilus group of lactic acid group of bacteria and Firmicutes phylum (1,2,3). Lactobacillus delbrueckii subsp. bulgaricus is one of the subspecies of

BlueBiotics Ultimate Care Review

Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Email-EDITORS’ CHOICE-           Overall Rating:          4.8/5 What Really Sets BlueBiotics UC Apart From The Rest? For years, BlueBiotics has been the most highly recommended and most effective probiotic supplement available. With their new supplement,

The Top 5 Best Prebiotic Supplements of 2020

Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn EmailDietary fibers contain a blend of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants that is unlike anything else we eat. For that reason, the scientific community has studied them extensively over the past few decades. The resulting list of

Image of a bowl of miso soup, which can contain the probiotic lactobacillus gasseri

Lactobacillus Gasseri

Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn EmailWhile bacteria are often associated with sickness, infection, and a host of other health issues, they are an essential part of a healthy GI system. The gut microbiome, consisting of countless bacteria found mostly in the

Image of a container of the best prebiotic supplement, BlueBiology 100% Plant Based Prebiotic

BlueBiology Prebiotic Review

Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn EmailBlueBiology’s BlueBiotics Ultimate Care probiotic supplement has been our preferred probiotic supplement for some time now and it’s what we recommend the most when people ask us about probiotics. So when BlueBiology came out with their

Image of the top 5 best probiotics

Top 5 Probiotics of 2020

Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn EmailWithin the past few years, the probiotics market has been EXPLODING. Doctors may have been prescribing them for a long time, but only recently have people started including these extraordinary supplements in their daily diets. Those

Image of a person holding prebiotic grains

What Are Prebiotics?

Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn EmailPrebiotics are non-digestible fibers, carbohydrates, and certain types of sugar that act as food for probiotic microorganisms that pass through the digestive system. By eating prebiotics or taking a prebiotic supplement, you can improve the balance

Image of a woman holding a glass of water taking probiotic supplement bifidobacterium longum in a pill

Bifidobacterium Longum: A Probiotic Bacteria

Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn EmailBifidobacterium longum is a rod-shaped, Gram-positive, anaerboic bacterium strain in the Bifidobacterium genus of the phylum Actinobacteria (1,2). Bifidobacteria are prokaryotes, which mean that they are unicellular organisms that do not have a membrane-bound nucleus, mitochondria,

Image of yogurt on a table from above, which can contain lactobacillus casei

Lactobacillus Casei

Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn EmailLactobacillus casei is a rod-shaped, gram-positive, non-spore forming bacterium strain in the Lactobacilli genus (1). It is found in many strains in lactic acid fermented food products such as sauerkraut, fermented meat and fish, sourdough, pickled

Image of yogurt, fruit and granola in a bowl on a table, which can contain the probiotic lactobacillus rhamnosus

Lactobacillus Rhamnosus

Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn EmailWhat is Lactobacillus rhamnosus? Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG is a form of naturally occurring bacteria that is commonly found in the genital and urinary tract of human females. It is one of the most widely used probiotic

Send this to a friend