Last Updated:
This is where you will find only the brands which passed our lab’s quality analysis. Our quality analysis, which is our basic supplement screening process, simply filters product that do not meet the following criteria:
- The supplement must contain at least 95% of the vitamin quantity claimed by its label (5% deterioration is the standard allowance for storage and delivery)
- The supplement must contain NO IMPURITIES OR ADDITIVES, such as artificial coloring, etc.
After the screening process, each product is graded according to additional criteria:
- Vitamin diversity – The variety of vitamins within each supplement. Finding a well-balanced supplement will promote overall health and helps to resolve broad-spectrum deficiencies.
- Potency – the amount of vitamins within the supplement, measured in mg.
- Price – self-explanatory, however it is important to remember that in most cases you get what you pay for.
You might notice that there are no gummy or chewable vitamins on this list, which is because gummies and chewables contain 40%-70% less vitamins and minerals than standard multivitamins. We’re looking for the best of the best.
As men and women have different dietary needs, we have included multivitamin options which are specific to either gender. In addition to our top picks for men and women, there are two general-purpose multivitamins and our top prenatal vitamin choice.
#1 Optimum Nutrition Opti-Men
Overall Rating: 4.5
Optimum Nutrition Opti-Men is a comprehensive blend of vitamins, minerals, and amino acids.
Optimum Nutrition has been around for a while and has gained a solid reputation for quality supplements. They also have a strong and loyal customer base and offer frequent discounts to new and returning customers.
Our analysis has shown that their multivitamin contains the promised ingredients listed on the label – which alone puts them above half of other multivitamin supplements.
Given the diverse nutrition profile, purity of ingredients, and positive customer reviews – this places Optimum Nutrition Opti-Men as our Best Multivitamin for Men of 2019.
Vitamin diversity: 4.25
Potency: 4.75
- High-Potency Multivitamin for Active Men. 75+ Ingredients in 4 Performance Blends. 25 Vitamins & Essential Minerals and 1 Gram of Free Form Amino Acids, 1,500 IU of Vitamin D
- We recommend that the product be stored in the original container and kept in a cool, dry place. Be sure to put lid on tight and do not leave containers open for extended time
- We are aware that some consumers have reported product crumbling when Opti-Men tablets are removed from the original container and put into pill carrying cases. The product is safe to consume. The crumbling is due to excess exposure to moisture in the environment when put into the pill carrying cases. There have been isolated reports of crumbling in original bottle as well. We are implementing changes to increase the integrity of the tablet when stored in all containers. You may notice a change in a color of the tablet as a result
#2 Garden of Life Vitamin Code For Women
Overall Rating: 4.5
Garden of Life is another great company with a solid reputation.
Our analysis showed excellent purity of ingredients and the promised amounts of each vitamin and mineral. Most importantly for a Women’s multivitamin, this supplement contains high amounts of calcium and magnesium – as well as other key nutrients that should be in any Women’s multivitamin.
Given the effective amounts and broad spectrum of the right vitamins and minerals, along with very positive customer ratings, Garden of Life Vitamin Code for Women earns the title of Best Multivitamin for Women of 2019.
Vitamin diversity: 4.5
Potency: 4.5
- MULTIVITAMIN SUPPLEMENT: Specially formulated multivitamin for women with breast support made from nutritious and RAW whole foods
- MULTIVITAMIN WITH PROBIOTICS: Vitamin Code Women's multivitamin includes live probiotics and enzymes plus antioxidants for extraordinary health and vitality
- WOMEN SPECIFIC: This women's vitamin includes folate, calcium, magnesium, zinc and Vitamin A, C, D3, E and B Complex for women's nutritional needs
#3 Centrum Adult Multivitamin
Overall Rating: 4.25
A solid general multivitamin with a greater diversity of vitamins than most competitors.
Vitamin diversity: 4.5
Potency: 4.0
- Includes 200 tablets of Centrum Adult daily multivitamin supplement for men and women
- Backed by over 35 years of nutritional science, Centrum is the most complete multivitamin, with Centrum's highest levels of Vitamin D3
- Age-adjusted for adults under age 50 with key nutrients to support energy, immunity and metabolism (2)*
#4 Carlson Labs Super 2 Daily
Overall Rating: 4.0
A potent alternative to our general vitamin supplement picks, targeting fewer vitamin quotas.
Vitamin diversity: 3.75
Potency: 4.25
Price: $46.90 / 120
- Helps maintain good health
- Packed with essential vitamins and minerals
- Provides the important omega-3s EPA and DHA
#5 Garden of Life Vitamin Code RAW Prenatal
Overall Rating: 4.0
Our overall Prenatal vitamin pick, the best vitamin for prenatal care!
Vitamin diversity: 3.5
Potency: 4.5
Price: $28.80 / 120
- PRENATAL MULTIVITAMIN: Specially formulated women's multivitamin made from nutritious RAW whole foods
- MOM TO BE: Our prenatal vitamin for women is designed for BOTH mom and baby during pregnancy and lactation
- PRENATAL MULTI: These prenatal includes probiotics, ginger, vitamin D and zinc for digestive support